Sunday, June 8, 2014

Bracebridge History and Why You Need To Know More Before Demanding Change


Late 1960's Early 1970's Depiction of Manitoba Street in Bracebridge looking south down the Queen's Hill. The brick building second on the left was the former Queen's Hotel, but in this vintage it was The Patterson Hotel, owned by Fenton Patterson.


Two close ups of the same Frank Johnston painting, this one showing the intersection of Manitoba Street and Dominion Street and the artist would have captured this image from the front of the former Uptown Esso Station owned by Ted Smith.

THERE'S MORE TO THE STORY - BUT MANY OF US ARE TOO COMMITTED TO "THE NOW"

WHAT YOU SHOULD KNOW ABOUT YOUR HOME COMMUNITY AND REGION; A HISTORY LESSON THAT WILL SERVE YOU WELL

     Although you might think that today's blog is aimed at you, it's not. If you have read this column for awhile, you're already up to speed on the importance of respecting historical precedents. It's just a little preamble I find is necessary, that possibly, one day, will be shared with those who are keen to change the community, at all costs. Yet have a nagging feeling there's more to consider than the logistics of earth moving and concrete infilling. But fail to understand why it is necessary to look back, before your plow forward. One of the great disadvantages to our region, is when we base decisions solely on economics, without any real concern, about what profound changes, can have on the social side of constituent lives. When collateral damage occurs, politicians and significant others, who enabled change to occur, look at themselves wondering what could have possibly gone wrong with their applied logic. Historians might have been able to shed some light on the impacts of changing the centre of town, for example, and opting for an urban model, suited to a much bigger community, in another locale. I've heard a lot of explanations after the fact, but the one thing they don't want to accept, is that a decision they made, didn't go according to plan. It happened on other occasions, in town history, and undoubtedly it will happen again. Collateral damage could be mitigated by asking the historians, before the trees are cut and the hole dug, if they see any negative aspects associated, with for example, selling off an urban parkland. Jubilee Park for example? This is my little opening editorial.

     There is a fine line, you see, between being historically sensitive, and obsessive, to the point of only desiring history as a way of thinking; even to the point of being a way of life. I have always been able to stay on the "now" side, and yet, I also know there is a danger of staying contemporary, without understanding the ripple effect, of what happened twenty or fifty years earlier, radiating on, into the future twenty to fifty years. This "living for the moment" stuff, is good for about ten minutes ahead, and then it just becomes future planning. But before I let loose, on this blogsite, with some intimate, modern era folktales, I would like to explain one aspect, that may be obvious to you in the family sense, but not so much, in terms of what makes our community tick.
     This series, revamped and renewed from my earlier 1990's column, published in "The Muskoka Advance," hinges on one historical reality above all else. History repeats. Not exactly, but it does repeat. If not factually, then by comparable circumstance. Socially, a lot of stuff repeats. Parallel situations, some harmless, some deadly. When you spend more than half your life, buried in the history of your hometown, and region, it can get pretty weird, when modern day events and situations, show up with striking parallels, a half century later. When you start comparing news clippings, dating back to the 1870's, up to, and including the present, it's pretty amazing how these current events repeat time and again. The people involved are different, and the circumstances will vary, but in essence, when you break them down detail by detail, it's startling to see how much like a carousel spinning, we really are in this mortal coil.
    I was struck by the editorial comment, a few months back, in the Bracebridge Examiner, about a group of young residents, who would like to return "the great," to the description of what has become their hometown. They were starting a Facebook campaign, I believe, to stir up some positive energy, to inspire the citizenry and town councillors. To help infuse some positive energy back into the community; which according to their observations, had become a tad lethargic in recent years. Part of it, was based on the failure of a number of Bracebridge mainstream retailers, and the unsightly look of vacant storefronts, on the cusp of the busy tourist season. I wanted to respond then, but I had too many other projects, here in Gravenhurst, to weigh in sensibly. Apparently, they were receiving a lot of interest, especially at Town Hall. I went to look for this site recently and couldn't find it, or maybe it was just taken down. I know that the town wasn't particularly pleased to have their performance, and shortcomings out there, on global display, especially in an election year.
     As I noted earlier, as primarily a Bracebridge and Muskoka historian, I wanted to explain, as kindly as I could, possibly in a letter to the editor, which I never actually wrote, that "great" was the wrong word to use, to describe their community. To my knowledge, the only time "great"  has been used in local history, up to the present, has been to describe the performance of athletes, winning curling rinks, hockey clubs, baseball teams, soccer clubs, and the "great" time had by all, at various parties, celebrations and assorted dedications. These were "great" events. I've never once referred or described, in about a billion pages of editorial copy,  Bracebridge, Gravenhurst, Port Carling, Huntsville, or Milford Bay as "great" places. They're all interesting and unique places but not "great." I might have said, "isn't it a great night," possibly while sitting on the balcony, of the former Manitoba Street house, once owned by Dr. Peter McGibbon, sipping a glass of wine, and watching over the comings and goings, in that picturesque, beautifully treed, wedge of urban landscape, known as Memorial Park. But if someone then, or now, was to ask me whether I would consider Bracebridge, a "great" town, I wouldn't have much to say on the matter, beyond a simple and direct "No! It is a town like many other towns. It does what a town is supposed to, and most of that, is to perform and function as a hometown where we reside, work, play and enjoy recreational, social and cultural pursuits. None of it has to do with greatness or being great.
     What I wanted to share with the well meaning folks, who were forwarding the plan, to push onward and upward toward greatness, is that they should, as a first step, spend some time at the Bracebridge Public Library, reading up on their town history. This, as a general rule, cuts the interest and determination in half. I've been in this forum many times, and there are a lot of self-appointed history makers, who believe a knowledge in contemporary affairs, is all that is needed to attain expert status. When I point out to some of these keeners, who plan to infuse change upon what they don't understand, that you really can't burden the top layer, without first knowing what platform you're reconstituting, for an even greater weight. To cut it short, what these young folk don't appreciate, is that community change is not like re-decorating, if it is intended to be profound and manageable. I've ragged on to councillors about the same thing, especially when they've absolutely ignored the historical consequences, of reconfiguring the town, to suit the agenda of the few. When for example, councillors decided to move the town hall, from the centre of the urban area, they paid no attention to the de-centralizing impact it would cause constituents. By one decision of empire building, they decided to get out of town, because for all intents and purposes, this is exactly what they did. Certainly, from the way I grew up to understand this town, and the tutoring I received from Bob Boyer, and other community historians, the town grew out from its centre, but always responsive to that core. When councillors did fundamentally the same, outward ho, when they re-established the recreation centre, and moved the high school to the fringes of the urban area, from the former prominence in the heart of town, it was another serious act of decentralization, for a town with limited growth possibilities. Bracebridge is a long way from citydom, but there were some who believed it was inevitable. That may be so fifty years from now. The changes made by moving the ball diamonds to the same vicinity as the town hall, and the recreation centre and school into the hinterland, it impacted the historical, traditional functioning of the former urban area. It caused a lessening of business activity to the main street, and likely many other businesses, because about nine hundred students were moved north. Now and in the future, the impact of these particular moves will be felt, and we can look back on those decisions either favorably or otherwise, as having been history changers; when all the proponents could think, at the time, was that there was going to be success all round.
     What you pick up as an historian, besides a lot of clutter and information, throbbing and bobbing in your head, is that this "foundation" issue should never be dismissed as unimportant. Or, at least, it is foolhardy to do so, because it references clearly, why and how, the very character we appreciate, of our hometown, has been sculpted by the masses over several centuries. I know stories that I can't repeat. I have been told many orally, that possess information that would not only hard to prove, but damaging to that image we have of hometown. This isn't surprising, and every town historian has a binder of stories, not ready for prime time viewing. I have a great many other stories, and recollections from those who were intimate to the moments, that are so important and integral to understanding local history; yet all I can offer, is this broad stroke appeal, that there's more to the story than what you read. And that we should all be reverent of the hidden, largely unknown chronicle of our history, that never made the front pages in any generation, from the beginning of town history. It's a heavy burden most of the time, because there are a hundred stories I'd like to write, that I simply can't, based on promises to family and sources. I've had journals and letters, and confidential correspondence, that infilled a lot of information I needed to know. And my point for writing about this today, is that this confidential, highly sensitive information, isn't available in any book in the Muskoka section of the local library, and it will never arrive there, for obvious reasons. Historians appreciate, that not everything is for public consumption, but at the same time, recognize how relevant it is, as part of this foundation structure, to use it as leverage in just about everything we write. We don't give away the story, or the sensitive information, but we use it none the less, as the means of creating a bigger portal, from which to rationalize and present community history. I suppose this reads a little suspicious, that I'm making this up, and that there is no secret stash of historical information. Think what you wish.
     When I write any local historical piece, with the contemporary purpose of informing the modernists, what their hometown is really all about, this file of stories (most I've never written down), are used like all wisdom acquired, and built upon carefully. When Suzanne asked me this morning, when we were talking about this, whether I would ever write these stories down, thoroughly, I had to pause for a moment, because it has always been my policy to avoid making any record that could find its way back into the community. Yet, there is a point, to having a record of the material, despite its sensitive content. I answered as I have many times before. I write each local heritage column, feature story for the press, or project history, with this knowledge as foundation. I would rather have the knowledge than not, because it keeps me from making mistakes in judgement, and I can't tell you how many times, I've benefitted from having this intimate knowledge, entering into a project where these unknown realities come into play. When people used to "go off the record" with me, when I was editor of The Herald-Gazette, there were times, when I thought I was going to go  nuts, trying to keep it sensibly tucked in my mind. As a rookie in this kind of stuff, I wasn't confident I could keep my hands off the keyboard, and putting the information into the very next issue, betraying the source. Over time, however, I learned that any information that helps me compose more competently and accurately, is worth having, even if I can't use it for immediate gain. In my years as a regional historian, I've been told thousands of "off the record" stories, that are tremendously relevant to the historical chronicle, but I am unable to release what I have been offered in confidence, for information only. So sometimes, in these blogs, I have to be slightly obscure, and a little evasive, but for each, there is a safe and sound platform of historical record, that has helped me understand the community I'm writing about, and the legacies of its thousands of residents, going all the way back to the late 1850's, as those first hand hewn cabins were being erected, on the patch of cleared earth, just above the cataract of the Bracebridge falls.
     I will share stories, in the coming weeks and months,  that will more clearly address, why you can't judge this town, yours or mine, wherever on this planet, by studying contemporary issues only. There is no way to change the direction or composition of a community, by imposition, that can be successfully accomplished, without reverence to what has come before, that created the social current that, as they say, runs deep. I've watched a lot of imposed change, because of economics, that have become mired in complication, because no one believed historical due diligence was in any way necessary. Sort of like building on quick sand, on the visual assumption that it was a good place to build, nuff said. Change can be imposed. But there are always implications. Look at Toronto. It's got a billion dollar problem with grid-lock. No kidding. Isn't that what happens when you exceed the limits of growth, and sensible proportion? Economics will never, ever trump historical evidence, and character. It might build on top of it, but there will always be a reckoning. The best advice. When in doubt, ask an historian for a little advice.

FROM THE ARCHIVES


The Patina of Home - The Amalgamation of Emotions and Fact

I like to retrace my youth spent in Bracebridge step by step. Literally. Physically. The art of the hike. The mindful jaunt in places familiar. I've taken many long strolls through my former neighborhoods, over the four seasons, just to see if by slim but hopeful chance, there's a ghost or two still wandering about from that era of the 1960's and 70's, when the town was on the cusp of what I feel has become a profound urbanizing change. I don't see them but I can feel their presence and it's not a bad or frightening thing to be in their company. I also write a ghost blog so the more the merrier!
There was a lot of history that wasn't recorded. It's not really the fault of historians past but the fact that most history of small towns in Ontario, for example, was tallied by newspaper reporters/editors, who purposely distanced fact from the "emotional facts......actuality of the event that took place." The borrowed news reports re-published in modern histories do not evoke much in the way of sentiment....because of course they were meant for the news pages where there is a strict format and protocol for presentation; a budget of words and a reduction of sentiment for sentiment's sake. It does however, leave a void of understanding. What was it like to watch a fallen soldier's body return home to the Bracebridge train station in a rough box......what was it like to stand on that platform with family who had some time earlier waved at their son as he headed out in defence of his country? Let the reader fill in the blanks. On re-write however, for the reader today, the old news reports have a corpse-like dryness about them, because they are hollow for the most part, of actuality.....like when the news commentator in the United States stated, in utter shock and horror.... "Oh, the humanity," when the great Zepellin caught fire and passengers dove, in flames, to their deaths. Events and personal tragedies that may have made the front pages of the weekly press, and into the hearts and souls of neighborhood folks then, are jammed into historical accounts now without accompanying explanation of what it all meant in human terms....not just in some writer's appreciation of the bare facts. Today these twists of fate are pretty much neglected unless conversation between hometowners enters that domain.
Events such as the death of two of my chums in a tunnel cave-in on Anne Street, just up the hill from the train tracks near Bass Rock, come to mind. No matter how many times it may re-appear in sundry mention in a feature article or book, unless there's some infilling, it becomes a news story only.....when in fact it was a community-shaping tragedy that affected the way we perceived our hometown fragility and our ability to save our children from a similar fate. When it was learned the boys had been trapped in the tunnel, neighbors and folks from all over, appeared on site with shovels, showing on their faces the very great fear of the unknown......that there may have been many others in that smothering hole in the side of the hill. Some who ran to that cave-in suspected their sons might be in there as well. Former Hospital Administrator Frank Henry, on hearing the news while at work, ran from the nearby medical facility with a shovel, he found in the maintenance department, to help dig the lads free. It was a Saturday and parents were frantic to connect with their youngsters situated at play all over town. My father phoned my mother Merle from the lumber yard where he worked, to find out if I was at home. I was. But I might not have been if not for a warning that came down the pike the night before, when several young lads asked their parents about helping our mates from school dig their army tunnel network the next day. When I announced my intention to trundle over to the same hillside, my mother stood in the doorway and said, "You're not going to be digging a tunnel today or ever.....and I don't care what you're friends think is a good idea....it's not....you can die if there's a cave-in." That was the statement made the night before. It's the reason I'm penning these thoughts now....because of any project I do get involved, I'm usually in the middle of everything going, including a tunnel dig. Just as I would have been on that rainy autumn day. I thought she might have changed her mind, or that possibly I could sneak past the sentry and wander over to Anne Street without my mother being any the wiser. By morning it was raining heavy and throughout most of the day it was a misty, cold ugliness. As it turned out, this was at least part of the problem that helped loosen a large portion of hillside, sliding down on top of the boys.
I will never forget the sombre mood of that town for weeks after. Students jammed the funeral home rooms to bid farewell to their chums and for many of us it was the first serious introduction to mortality. It happened on numerous other occasions, where accidents and general misadventures led to the death of friends......hockey playing mates, baseball colleagues, kids from the neighborhood who drowned or were involved in traffic mishaps. Sickness claimed quite a few others and most of us admittedly didn't understand why the young and resiliant were succumbing. For every community milestone, every accomplishment from a provincial sports honor to celebration of the Cavalcade of Color, there was no escaping the reality there was a patina of town life that was a precarious mix of good and bad, happiness and misery, new life being born to the citizenry and others taken away.....sometimes suddenly.
I can remember hearing about a traffic accident, as a kid, that happened on old Highway II at the intersection near The Pines Home for the Aged......a grisly tale that has stuck with me to this day because of what rescuers had to deal with at the scene. The word went around that summer afternoon that a head-on collision near the intersection had resulted in many serious injuries to mulitiple occupants of both vehicles. There were sirens coming from all over. We knew it was bad just by the responding vehicles..... , fire, ambulance and the police. From where we lived on Alice Street, much of the action passed down nearby Toronto Street on the way to the hospital. When the fire department arrived they knew at least one of the vehicles was going to require ripping apart to free the occupants. Before they could finish extracation of the injured, flames broke out in the wreckage, and in seconds what was left of the car was engulfed in flames. They had no chance to do anything for those people inside, who began screaming in pain from the encroaching fire. It was told to us kids, sitting at the time with adults at our apartment on Alice Street, that the firemen felt like screaming along with the victims, because their agony was as great....having to live with the fact they were forced to watch people die knowing their rescue efforts could not be successfully mounted in time. I could not, would not ever forget those words, and it was as if I had been a witness myself....it became that real for me. I knew some of the firemen. What a terrible experience for them to live with for the balance of their lives.....and they had seen many more gruesome situations; yet I am reminded that they had experienced thousands of other calls when they were able to make successful rescues and save lives.....save buildings from burning and ward of total catastrophe by their expert efforts. It was that bitter sweet patina of everyday life.
There were many times in my childhood, in Bracebridge, when like everyone else who appreciates the dynamic of life, when shock and sadness entered into one's heart and soul, and affected the interpretation of everything else for weeks and months. It was a community like all the rest. There were serious accounts of misadventures we listened intently to at dinner-time; reports, hearsay, gossip of unfortunate family circumstances, tales of business failures, marriage break-ups, a few affairs of the heart, crime, assaults and some less serious news about school mates (some from prominent families) caught for shoplifting or public drunkeness. As I got a little older there were numerous stories about those same chums getting caught with drugs and related items, smoking down at Bass Rock where we used to swim..... and where we'd get a real kick talking to hippies and draft dodgers, Americans trying to avoid the horrors of the Vietnam War by hinding out in the hinterland of Ontario.
The Hunt's Hill lads used to hang-out near the railway station on hot sumer afternoons, awaiting the coveted Toronto run, pondering whether this would be the day to jump a boxcar and head to the city for some fun. They came and went over those many years and we never jumped on rolling stock. We did however, get on boxcars in the rail yard and we met up with more than a few hobos heading down to the Jungle they kept in rotating locations just up the overgrown embankment from the Muskoka River.....where yes they did occasionally enjoy an invigorating bath in the moonlight.
If you sat by the rails for long enough you were sure to see some interesting stuff going on at the adjacent Albion Hotel that I think had a better history earlier in the century than it was gaining in the 1960's, by way of the patrons it kept. It wasn't uncommon at all to see a bouncer run a drunk patron's head into the door on the way out onto the tarmac.....which obviously spoke volumes about the misconduct inside. The guy would crawl around for a few moments, dust himself off, comb his hair, and shadow-box a little while giving a lecture to the bouncer, then long gone, about "just who do you think you are buddy, throwing me out like that......I'll show you a thing or two." Five minutes of composure-gathering later, he'd try to get back in that bar again......and we loved every moment of it. Sure as we bet, he'd coming flying out a little further the second time with the bouncer's arm on his shoulder and wasteband of the pants, and down he'd go in a lump of humanity. I've watched as many as three patrons bounced the same way minutes apart. It may not be the part of history that is seen worthy of ink these days (or even then) but by golly it happened, it was funny as hell, and I witnessed this social, cultural heritage close enough to smell the booze and hear their heads hitting the door on the way out.
Public drunkeness wasn't a rarity even in the earliest days of our community. We had a lot of logging types in this town before the turn of the century, as did Gravenhurst, and it imprinted pretty harshly on the local constables. The loggers coming from the camps were a force to be reckoned with, and being rowdy was just part of the rugged lifestyle garnered from an industry known for its dangers, demands for the utmost courage, and reckless abandon. Being trapped for long periods in the camp made the escape so much more desirable, and misadventure was normal course....and the lock-up showed the wear and tear on its hinges. As well, homesteaders here had no choice but to be a tough, unyielding, stubborn lot because failure here could mean a slow agonizing death due to starvation out on the homestead. Even if you lived in town you were unmistakably a pioneer in the north woods regardless of urban situation. To say we were hewn from a rough and tumble first citizenry, well, you'd be right. From the late 1850's Muskokans who wanted to remain here made sacrifices. There were disadvantages on top of disadvantages and many didn't make the cut....left the region for some other locale, or perished with dreams of a prosperous homestead still in their hearts. Some of my wife's family, during this pioneer period, were known as the Three Mile Lake Wolves, for their temperment, and with Irish glee they would join arms at one end of the main street, stretch across the width of the rough lane, and with as many as four hardy brawlers, beckon anyone tough enough to stand in their way as they marched toward the town falls. Legend? Nope! Fact!
In the following blogs, some that were formerly published in Curious; The Tourist Guide, I have provided an honest appraisal of what it meant to me, to be considered a local yocal......how it felt after many years of being transplanted from the city, and attached to this new hometown. As I had been a keen observer throughout my childhood, of what constituted the tally of daily life and times of any worthy hometown.....I didn't proceed as a writer/historian with any misconception or lack of appreciation for what history had etched in its wake......like the glacier grinding over the Canadian Shield. What I had seen and experienced......it was a critical background reference that gave me an exceptional insight. As a fledgling editor, having arrived back to my hometown, hoping to make a name for myself as an adult citizen, I knew in advance of my first published piece that it was going to be a precarious balance to represent fairly all the trials, tribulations, joys and sorrows, losses and victories.....and avoid at all cost, making it ever seem as if the local citizenry couldn't cope with any situation it was to face. Afterall it had survived the wickedly difficult pioneer economy, two wars, a Great Depression and a myriad of successes in businesses that went bust as did so many dreams. It has worn its discontent bravely and survived despite adversity....just like thousands of other good hometowns that realize that the definition of prosperity means being able to turn misfortune into advantage......picking up where one task was left off and finishing the job.
My own critics argue that I am too open with my opinions, and to glaring with the facts I present. In response I carry on with blatant disregard and contempt.......because I have never as a citizen, a newspaper editor, or historian come upon anything in the past or present, no matter what the weight of its negative revelation, that couldn't be handled by citizens at large and time. And afterall that's what makes a hometown.....well.....a "home", being able to move on despite. We are not immune to the dastardly circumstances......of crime, corruption, and malice....why would we be? It's all part of our history like it or not. As the earth continues to turn, resolution and restitution will occur just as it always has, and we will recover and rejoice all over again......but it is imprudent to forget how we got from there to here in 150 odd years. I'd like to believe we've learned something about our capabilities to survive against what is often considered insurmountable.
Here are some editorial pieces about my hometown I've composed in the past 12 months. You don't have to know much about Bracebridge, or anything at all about its past, to relate to the stories.....which for all intents and purposes could have been generated from your own hamlet, village, town or city. Please enjoy! The first one has a Christmas backdrop!
Respecting the spirits of Christmas past
My contemporaries in the community press sought out the editorship of The Herald-Gazette, in Bracebridge, because it seemed from an underling perspective, like a politically powerful and socially influential position. They had visions of world domination, I think, not simply the fair and unbiased representation of community life and events.
It afforded the chosen-one the very great and time-honored privilege, to occupy the creaking old chair behind the oak desk, the one with a deep patina of sweat and ink imprinted into the grain, attained honestly from the actuality of many milestones of local history. To be editor one had to be cognizant of all things past and present, yet be insightfully inspired, no less courageous, to willingly venture into the abyss of uncertainty down a dark and winding trail. Well, that’s a tad dramatic!
How many of those long adrenalin, emotion driven editorial races to deadline, were pounded into that oak desktop? Fist thumps onto its surface. "Let’s put this paper to bed!"
It was situated in the second biggest office in the century old building on Dominion Street, and it afforded the occupier thusly, the right to select or compose the lead editorials for the weekly edition. Not to mention having the responsibility to bark out orders to reporters and lay-out staff, about what was going to make the front page, and what copy would fill up the white space further back amongst the food store ads.
I wasn’t the youngest editor of The Herald-Gazette but possibly the youngest non-family member to take the helm of this established publication. It wasn’t the only paper serving the community, and in fact, when I was appointed to the editorship in the early 198 0’s, there was a fierce battle being waged between competing publishers to win over advertisers and attain the highest weekly readership.
I had apprenticed with a sister publication, The Beacon, in the Township of Georgian Bay, and felt a little out of my league when the publisher first offered me the editor’s job, in Bracebridge, when the former head honcho was transferred to another community newspaper. While scared out of my wits to take the helm of one of the District of Muskoka’s best known publications, I had achieved exactly what I had intended after returning home from studies at York University in Toronto. I wanted to be an editor with Muskoka Publications. It simply came about five years sooner than I had planned.
I didn’t care about the political weight of editorship and I had no intention of changing one molecule of the tradition established by George Boyer and family, who had built the newspaper’s foundation brick by brick decades before I’d even seen the first light of new life.
I used to work many late nights hunched over that gouged, pen-imprinted, gnarled old desktop during the first year of my multi-year tenure, feeling a huge sense of pride being able to maintain the HG’s print tradition, carrying on a legacy of fine writers, and powerful editorialists. I felt in awe to be truly ingrained then in the history of my community. At times I still felt like a punk kid running amuck in the neighborhood, like my rapscallion days growing up on Bracebridge’s east side as part of the Hunts Hill gang, a notoriously pacifist bunch of lads who were distinctly better hockeyists than pugilists. Here I was dictating the editorial content for a much closer, in-person history, and I was astounded by the faith of the publisher, Hugh Mackenzie, who allowed me the greatest of freedom to represent the good and bad of community life and times.
I can so clearly recall one rather poignant news-desk vigil, on a blustery night on the cusp of that year’s Christmas vacation. I had been at the helm about a half year and we’d just finished the special holiday edition of the paper that afternoon, and heartily consumed a few cartons of eggnog in celebration. There may have been a trace of rum stirred in as well. What a keenly wonderful moment it was that night, in the solace of an empty newsroom amidst the splendid haunts of this historic building, to feel that sense of connectedness to all the heritage of this Ontario community. All I had to do was walk two flights of stairs to the basement to connect with the physical archives representing well over a hundred years. The history of Bracebridge was right there in huge and bulky compilations overflowing shelves and tables. I was in awe to stand there and consume the legacy of which I was now a part.
While my staff colleagues had their opinion about my leadership, and my zeal for political power, they might have been quite confounded by the fact I actually was quite humbled by the position. I felt more unworthy than cocky, and there wasn’t a day that went by, when I didn’t think about my shortfalls and inexperience captaining such an important community asset. Yet there were moments, such as that particular pre-Christmas vigil, when I allowed myself the benefit of doubt, and thoroughly enjoyed the sensation of being editor of The Herald-Gazette….despite the misgivings that I was unworthy of the responsibilities bestowed.
When I walked away from the news building that evening, and looked back through the wind-driven snow, it was as if a manufactured, nostalgic old movie scene wrenched from the archives. It needed a sentimental last-word, a line Bogart might have uttered about time and place, event and remembrance, life of old, life anew, the end of one chapter, the beginning of a fresh new perspective. I may have even looked a little like Bogie, at that precise moment, my turned-up coat collar and askew hat adorned with snow, staring back at the history of only moments ago, yet pondering what the future might hold…..Christmas yet to be. And in that illumination of snow against nighfall, there was that sense of peace we dream of when all the world seems to make perfect sense, and we trundle joyfully through the winter night with great expectation. It was as if, at that moment, I was walking the same path as an editor from the 1920’s, or one winter’s eve during the Great Depression, or during the Second World War, our footfall being the same. All the years, all the events, all the memorable moments were imprinted here, and I was only too pleased to embrace it all….that year and for every year since, that I have been contently employed writing about my hometown and home region of Ontario.

Saturday, June 7, 2014

Bracebridge and The Folks Who Were Always Willing To Lend A Hand

The well worn pages from Bob Boyer's "A Good Town Grew Here"

THE WAY IT WAS, AND WHY MY FAMILY ADJUSTED TO SMALL TOWN LIFE AND TIMES, FASTER THAN MOST

BRACEBRIDGE FOLKS GAVE US A BREAK, IN SO MANY WAYS

     I live in Gravenhurst. But I will always have a soft-spot for my old hometown. There have been times during my residency, in both South Muskoka towns, that I found myself being overly critical, and a tad insensitive in print, to the point of spewing outright negativity. I've been a community writer long enough, to be entitled to make some suggestions, and offer the occasional critique, but always balanced by the unyielding truth, that I have enormous respect for both towns. There are some who will read today's blog, and feel I am, in an editorial sense, trying to smooth over the ruffled feathers of past critiques, by unleashing a barrage of positive recollections, and excessively sweet overviews; of what it was like, for instance, to be a poor city kid, dumped into a rural neighborhood by circumstance, of my father's new employment. After about thirty years of thinking about those early years, transplanted into so called "God's Country," (and feeling seriously out of place) I now feel more satisfied, and comfortable, writing this style and theme of retrospective. A lot less intensive, and maudlin, than if I'd written the same piece, even a decade earlier. So I've beaten the romanticism and sentimentality down to a dull roar, although not diminishing the truth, of how I feel today, and how my parents felt, having spent their last days, of this mortal coil, living in the same town, that willingly adopted them in the mid 1960's.
     When our family moved to Bracebridge, so my dad could assume a managerial role, at the historic Shier's Lumber Company, we brought with us, as you might expect, an urban go-go-go mentality. We had left Burlington, and the subdivision of Mountain Gardens, in the late winter of 1966, but when we closed our apartment door for that last time, we forgot to shut-in our urban arrogance. Which by the way, had nothing at all to do with personal wealth, but everything to do with expectation. Although by accounting terms, we were a hair's breadth from being totally broke, only having enough money to buy food, and gas, for our failing, crumbling-into-orange dust, Vauxhall sedan, we still felt an unspecified prominence, being city-folks, coming to what my mother described, as being a "Sleepy Hollow."
    My parents were in for some rather stark realities, as the job didn't work out for my father, and seeing as we were living in a company-owned house, up on the extension of Toronto Street, we also became "city folks down on their luck, all of a sudden homeless, stuck without resources, in a small, small town." Ed would go back to Shiers on two other occasions, after unspecified negotiations, between boss and sales manager, and after a few months, quit again, following a similar dispute, with the then owner, Bob Jones; leaving us back in the same impoverished situation as before. The only difference was that we had found another place to live, courtesy the landlords of 129 Alice Street, known otherwise as the Weber Apartments. I think the rent for a third floor, front, two bedroom apartment, was a hundred dollars a month, and we had difficulty meeting that obligation. There was a difference. The Webers weren't typical landlords. They were too accommodating to be good at their job. Lots of renters caught a break from Wayne and Hilda, and some took advantage. I know we always paid-up eventually, but I knew several others who skipped out, late at night, sticking the Webers with months of unpaid rent.
     I think the transformation of the Currie family, from urban to rural sentiment, happened quicker, than for average urbanites, who decided in the 1960's, to get "back to the land," and restore themselves in rural serenity. I think the main reason, for our speedy adaptation, to a slower paced, less stressful town life, was due to our succession of unfortunate circumstances. First of all, I must admit, that when we lived in Burlington, we had a very small group of family friends, and most of them were neighbors in our newly constructed apartment building, prominently, and starkly standing (without trees) on the bald corner lot, of Mountain Gardens Road, and the extension of Brant Street. Ed worked at a lumber company in Hamilton, I believe, and Merle was employed by the Imperial Bank of Commerce, but I'm not sure where the branch was located. I know she travelled considerable distance to get there. When we moved from Harris Crescent, and the Nagy Apartments (which I adored and didn't want to leave), Merle took a job at the local pharmacy in the strip mall, across from where we lived. I got to see her more than my dad, because I used to frequent the stores in this plaza, and she had a good vantage point out the drug store window, to see me crossing the busy road. If I could see her, she could see me, so I played it safe, and was patient to cross. Where as, on other occasions, I darted, ran, meandered, all very dangerously. Merle supported the idea of moving to the country, because there was less traffic, and she wouldn't have to worry so much, about her son being hit and killed by a car.
     Living on Alice Street, upon the rise of land, bordering the west side of the black snaking course, of the Muskoka River, known as Hunt's Hill, was conveniently situated for car-less folks. It was only a couple of blocks from the main street, and perfect for walking to buy our groceries. When our Vauxhall finally quit, for good, its wheels collapsing sideways, at about the same time, and we had to hoof-it for a few months, we would walk down to Lorne's Marketeria, on Manitoba Street, every Friday night, to get our cart full of groceries; and then, feeling some distinction of importance, have them put in a box, for delivery later on Saturday morning. We did this for quite awhile, and it wasn't all that inconvenient. I don't think they charged for delivery back then, and seeing as we couldn't afford a car, it worked out well economically.
     In those first two years, from 1966 to 1968, we depended on the kindness of strangers, let me tell you. But they weren't strangers for long, truth be known. That was the biggest difference of living in a small town, versus living in a significantly populated subdivision, of a major city. We had ten times more friends, than we had ever made, living in the city. First of all, my dad eventually found work, after three tries at Shier's Lumber, with the newly opened, Building Trades Centre, with owner brothers, Paul and Irvin Robson, who saved us from destitution. But you know, we couldn't have ever been destitute of spirit, living at 129 Alice Street, or in Bracebridge generally, because of all the new and generous friends we met from the first week we had called it our home town. Hilda and Wayne Weber were two of the kindest people we have ever known, and although we never understood how they got along as a couple, all we knew at the time, was that it must have been God's will that we connected; they were our forgiving landlords, and we became their close family friends. I soon became responsible for lawn cutting, although I know Wayne often referred to me, under his breath, as "that littler Christ-er," especially when I launched a powerful stream, of mixed lawn clippings and dirt, at the open screened windows, of basement apartments. "Turn the lawn mower around Teddy, for God's sake; can't you see where the cuttings are coming from," Wayne would yell at me, followed by his apology through the screens, to the basement dwellers, coughing from the dirt cloud aimed at their sofas. As far as generosity, I don't know how many times, Hilda and Wayne let my parents slide on the rent due, and believe me, their kindnesses in that regard weren't forgotten. They were a peculiar couple, and fought like cat and dog, but when it came down to benevolence, let me tell you, those folks would have given us anything we needed, including a short term loan, a room in their house, or transportation whenever it was needed.    We soon learned from the Webers, the difference between urbanites and the urban condition, and what it meant to be a rural dweller. Believe me, there were hundreds of examples, and we had dozens more friends, than we had ever made in the same type of apartment circumstance, living in Burlington. I suppose my parents didn't care about this back then, because they didn't have financial problems, and they both had decent jobs.
     I can remember when my mother, Merle, was working for the Bank of Nova Scotia, in Bracebridge, part time, and watching the tears streaming down her face, after finding out, by phone, she had been turned down for a personal loan, at the place she worked. At that point we wouldn't have had anything to use as collateral anyway. So giving us money was a high risk. It was coming up to Christmas, and she wanted a little extra money to cover expenses of the season, and prepare for rent on the first of January. She knew that the bank had quite a few holiday days, and her earnings for December wouldn't be enough. Ed was working but, if I remember correctly, he was only a part-time bartender at the Holiday House, working for Timmy Allchin. I remember Merle being pretty upset that Christmas, until a few days before. She came home one evening, with a huge smile on her face. Her boss, Ralph Melvin, had fronted her the money she had applied for, but had been originally denied. I've always suspected Ralph, and yes he was that kind of man, gave her money out-of-pocket, to see us through the Christmas holiday. Ralph didn't know my mother very well, as she had only just started at the bank, and he only knew my father, from casual chats, when he met my parents shopping, or walking along the main street. Yet he felt we were trustworthy to repay the load. And Merle did repay Ralph after only a month. But we never forgot his kindness to our family, and I must admit, when I was editor of The Herald-Gazette, I found it almost impossible, while covering town council, to find anything to critique of Councillor Melvin's performance, on behalf of constituents.
     I remember once, getting into a serious disagreement with a newspaper manager, about the plan to include Ralph in a particularly nasty editorial, being planned for that issue. I refused to have any part of it, or give my approval to planting it on the editorial page. I think the editorial ran, but was toned-down a lot, from what had been proposed originally. Was I right to show favourtism to this man, because of a kindness once? I was the editor of a small town newspaper, in the rural climes of Ontario. Of course it was the right thing to do, under the circumstances, and although I would have failed a journalism course, at university, by acknowledging this bias, what I'm admitting, is that discretion was, and is a big part of the job; in a community where we see each other three times each day. They may have handled this different in the big city, but these were our neighbors, and I had hundreds of similar circumstances to handle, over the years of my editorship. This isn't to suggest, that we would have refused to run stories about crime, and criminal charges, just because it involved our friends; but there were times, when we did defer, on lesser issues, such as political critiques, because we understood circumstances more clearly, as friends. I can't make this read acceptably, simply because favoritism isn't a good thing, especially as regards newspaper coverage. Yet, I was just one editor, in a long line, and tradition, of small town press staff, who had to make similar value judgements like this; so I wasn't the first to be influenced by an intimate knowledge of our fellow citizens. I didn't and couldn't have, by terms of employment, have demanded that the editorial be killed, before it hit the presses, but it was the closest I came to quitting a job I loved.
     What I carried on to the news business, in the late 1970's, were the memories of how our family had been treated, especially during those first five years, as city transplants, in Bracebridge. We lived in a building, which I recall as being a sort of latent hippy commune, where everyone borrowed from one another, and most residents left their doors open when they were home; inviting neighbors to drop in, whenever in the mood. The doors only closed at bedtime, or when residents were out of the building. It was the perfect place to live, for folks down on their luck, because everyone who lived there, for those years, became our family friends. We had a lot in common. A lack of resources. It was incredible, and empowering for us, in so many ways. These folks all had their respective problems, and none at the time, were particularly well off, and that made us feel slightly more normal. We certainly didn't feel it necessary to impress our neighbors with material extravagances, and Merle and Ed were at card parties, in neighbor apartments, on most Saturday nights during those years; and in the summer, their nights were spent in a lawnchair ring, out on the front lawn, where some kind neighbor would barbecue some hot dogs for the gang. The kids would spread blankets over the cool grass, on steaming hot summer nights, and we'd lay there looking up at the star-scape, listening to our parents, laughing through the night, and story-spinning. It was just a neat sharing environment, and food and beverage, was always generously offered to those who didn't have their own. I've written volumes about these years, because of this fascination, about how our family was spared, and supported, by this community generosity, in such a wide variety of forms. Including hiring me to mow the lawn every two weeks, and sweep the halls of the building, even though I routinely did a crappy job. Hilda and Wayne knew my parents couldn't afford to give me an allowance, so they found ways of paying me to do some apartment chores. I did help out around the property, or at least I thought I did; and now I feel bad about whining how hard it was to do these basic chores, for five buck a pop.
     It didn't matter whether I was at the arena, or at Jubilee Park, or hanging around Bill Elliot's five cents to a dollar store, on Manitoba Street, I found this same level of caring and kindness bestowed the former city kid; who by the way, used to brag about still being a city kid at heart. I said to Suzanne, one day, a short while ago, that it had been the best case scenario for our family, to have faced hard times in Bracebridge, than in the city at that time; when so few knew us, and cared to change that particular status quo. And my parents were unhappy with their jobs in Burlington, so sooner or later, one of my parents would have quit, and created an economic crisis. The friends and soon-to-be friends, we soon made in Bracebridge, didn't really care about our financial circumstance, but considered us one of the mix of citizens, who might later become important resources in the community. It's exactly what I thought about, the very first day, I sat at my new "editor's desk," after my advancement at The Herald-Gazette, the oldest newspaper in town. I was so honored to be editor, in part, because it afforded me an opportunity, to add my own experiences and sentiments, about the home town experience; and this would influence the editorial decision for years to come. I was proud to represent the history of the newspaper, and what the Boyer family had accomplished during their long-time stewardship; and I felt it incumbent, to carry on traditions despite format changes, and an ever evolving readership in a growing town. At, by the way, a very enterprising time for business investment. It was growing beyond its small town quarters, and expanding outward into the pastures of former heritage farms. I did, in this vein, have the opportunity to acknowledge my appreciation, back to the town, for helping my family adjust to rural living, and bestowing so many kindnesses on a family out of its comfort zone.
     When I first began writing my "Bracebridge Sketches," column, for the Sunday morning, free paper, known as "The Muskoka Advance," in the early in the 1990's, I began publishing stories about the Alice Street apartment, the days of Bamfords and Lil & Cec's corner stores, up on Toronto Street, and about so many of the good friends we had made, back in our own dark days of the late 1960's, when honestly, we were close too packing-up, and heading back to the city. It was the first time in local newspaper history, that a writer would confess such intimate confessionals, that weren't just about landmarks, events, occurrences and local history itself. I suppose, I made it a living history, because most of the people, I was writing about then, were very much alive, and still carrying on their acts of benevolence. They were however, a little shocked to find out, via my column, just how much they had helped my family weather their personal crisis. Sometimes these folks would call me, and offer thanks for my comments, such as Father Heffernan, who was always so kind and encouraging, on the playground of Bracebridge Public School, or anywhere else we met in town; even on the ice pad of the arena. A few people I wrote about, didn't make any comment at all, and there were others, I think, who felt I shouldn't have written about them at all, because their benevolence was just part of who they were; nothing out of the ordinary, or deserving of a column, dedicated in their honor. But it these columns, weren't written just to thank individuals or groups of people, such as the residents of 129 Alice Street. They were written, you see, to acknowledge the fine cluster of good citizens in a decent home town, who cared enough about us newcomers, to offer hospitality above and beyond anything we could have expected. I wanted the town itself, to know, that we had made the correct decision, at the perfect time, to relocate to Bracebridge. And because of all our new friends, made so quickly during those first years, we time and again, decided that our gains in this new community were more important, than job offers elsewhere. My father was a career lumberman, and he was offered all kinds of positions with Southern Ontario companies, but he turned them all down, to stay with Building Trades, in Bracebridge. As a result of my parents' contentment to stay in town, it of course influenced me, and I couldn't wait to return back home, after finishing university studies in Toronto.
     My parents moved to Parry Sound, in the late 1970's, because Ed had become a partner in a local lumber company, but after four years, had decided to move back to Bracebridge. It was where they would live in retirement, at Bass Rock apartments, on the Muskoka River, and would eventually pass away; right to the end, benefitting from the unmistakable embrace of old friends and new, in the hometown they once thought, they'd never get used to. Yet came to adore, in so many ways, because of what it didn't have. There are times, when I become a little sappy about those early years, and possibly I expend too much sentiment to be taken seriously as an historian. I remarked to Suzanne a few weeks back, that I'd very much like to live in that apartment once more, for a year or so, just to write about those days; set up the same apartment the way it was when my parents lived there. "That's just weird," she replied. "You're an historian. You know full well you can't go back." Of course, I know differently. Sometimes, frankly, quite to the contrary, it's kind of hard to get back to the present. I'm never in a hurry.
     A lot of young folks and new residents to this part of the world, don't know our communities the same way. Admittedly, they weren't here back in the 1960's and 70's, and can't be expected to have the same sensitivities, as I possess, in retrospect, of a much different community. Yet, I think they should make an effort, to learn more about their hometown, and all the exceptional folks who made it a good and caring place to live. There will always be residents, past and present, who failed to benefit, the way my family did, for any number of reasons. It's impossible to broad stroke this period, with one overview, and not find those who feel the opposite, or at least contrary, regarding my assertions. It will be much the same today, although there is no columnist as intimate with the past, and former citizens, as me, to applaud or critique. It would however, infill a lot of social history, as it is the one huge void in our town's story. The intimate side. I've seen it, experienced it, and benefitted from it. Of course, it can be said, that by circumstance, I'm biased. As a newspaper reporter, this reference would be insulting. As a columnist, it is part and parcel of the assignment.
     I wrote this today, mournfully so, thinking about this week's loss of former Bracebridge Councillor, and main street businessman, Bruce McPhail, and his wife, Ruth, who were both killed in a motor vehicle accident, while travelling in the State of Nebraska. The McPhails were both very active in the community, and their contributions to the well being of Bracebridge, goes back decades. When it is held, the memorial service, for these two fine citizens, will be one of the largest in town history; because of their dedication to home, and their many friends and life-long associations. This is how they will be remembered. They were builders of our social-cultural legacy, in South Muskoka, along with thousands of folks just like them, largely unsung, but always committed to assisting others, sometimes, even by simply infusing enthusiasm, and generating inspiration to carry-on.
     It was also sad to read about Coray Schroeder's passing this week, and Suzanne and I want to extend heartfelt sympathy to the family. Suzanne was a colleague of Coray's, and her husband, Glen, while teaching at Bracebridge and Muskoka Lakes Secondary School during the 1980's and 90's. Corey was an untiring volunteer in the community, and her name showed up time and again, in support of important initiatives, of which, in many ways, we have benefitted as area residents. She will be missed.
     We don't often devote time, just to analyze how, and by what means, we have earned, and maintained, the credit of being a home town, and not just a cluster of citizens. If we were to spend a little time, pondering this issue, we would recognize fully, just how much sculpting has gone on, by our enterprising, creating citizenry, to meet the demands of the future. But we can't ever fully appreciate how hard it all was, unless we pay respect to those builders, each who contribute something to what we have ultimately become.
     As I enjoyed those many wonderful years of stewardship, as editor of The Herald-Gazette, and as columnist previously, of "Bracebridge Sketches," I have wrapped myself in history, once more, as may be my folly to suffer. I suppose I have done so, to feel the close comfort again, in my elder years, of so many vivid memories, of those who made our lives better, and more interesting; yet we never told them so, when we had the chance. This newly re-visited blog / column, will address some of these shortfalls, that I have been neglectful in correcting.
     Thanks so much for taking a few moments out of your busy day, to visit with me, here at our little commune of "Bracebridge Sketches."





Friday, June 6, 2014

Bruce and Ruth Anne McPhail: Cecil Porter: and another day of history in South Muskoka

This main stay Bracebridge History was signed by the author and the printer, the late Jack Wells formerly a pressman with the Herald-Gazette
1938 photo of Queen's Hotel minus its balconys
A presentation silver tray to Bracebridge Fire Brigade Chief Simmons upon his retirement in 1947. Image courtesy of family member Chris Thompson of Gravenhurst


WELL RESPECTED BRACEBRIDGE BUSINESSMAN, FORMER TOWN COUNCILLOR, AND HIS WIFE, KILLED IN CAR ACCIDENT IN THE UNITED STATES

     SUZANNE AND I JUST NOW, LEARNED FROM A FRIEND HERE IN GRAVENHURST, THAT WELL KNOWN BRACEBRIDGE BUSINESSMAN, AND FORMER TOWN COUNCILLOR, BRUCE MCPHAIL, LONG TIME OWNER OF "MCPHAIL'S MENS WEAR," ON MANITOBA STREET, AND HIS WIFE RUTH ANNE, WERE BOTH KILLED, THE RESULT OF A HEAD-ON COLLISION, WITH A TRANSPORT TRUCK, WHILE MOTORING IN THE STATE OF NEBRASKA. BRUCE WAS A LONG-TIME MEMBER OF THE BRACEBRIDGE ROTARY CLUB, AND AN ACTIVE SUPPORTER, OF MANY COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT INITIATIVES, AND WAS MOST OF ALL, A LOVER OF HISTORY IN ALL ITS DIVERSE FORMS.
     THERE IS A WELL KNOWN PHOTOGRAPH OF BRUCE MCPHAIL, STANDING WITH FELLOW TOWN COUNCILLORS, ON THE STEPS OF THE FORMER MUNICIPAL OFFICE, ON DOMINION STREET, WITH THEN LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR, PAULINE MCGIBBON, WHO HAD BEEN ATTENDING A SPECIAL CEREMONY, RECOGNIZING THE ACHIEVEMENTS OF SEVERAL CITIZENS OF BRACBRIDGE. IT IS PUBLISHED ON PAGE 267 OF THE BOOK, "A GOOD TOWN CONTINUES - BRACEBRIDGE, 1915 TO 1999." IT WAS IN 1968, ACCORDING TO THIS UPDATED TOWN HISTORY, THAT BRUCE PURCHASED THE FORMER "REID'S SPORTSWEAR," STORE FROM MR. AND MRS. STU REID. IN 1998 BRUCE AND THREE OTHER FORMER KINSMEN, WERE TREATED AS SPECIAL GUESTS, FOR THE FIFTIETH ANNIVERSARY OF THE BRACBRIDGE CLUB. THOSE SPECIAL GUESTS INCLUDED BRUCE MCPHAIL, FORMER MAYOR JIM LANG, JOHN SHIRE AND DON COATES.
     I ALWAYS ENJOYED A VISIT WITH THE MACPHAILS, WHEN BRUCE AND I WOULD GET A CHANCE TO SHARE STORIES ABOUT OUR MUTUAL FRIEND, ARCHIVIST / . HISTORIAN, HUGH MACMILLAN, AN ARDENT RESEARCHER OF SCOTTISH HERITAGE IN CANADA. THE TOPICS OF DISCUSSION WERE LIMITLESS, FROM THE OUTDOORS, AND HIS MANY CANOEING ADVENTURES, TO THE HISTORIC CONSTRUCTION OF BIRCH BARK CANOES. ONE OF THE FAVORITE STORIES, WAS REMINISCING HOW THE FLOATILLA OF VOYAGEUR CANOES, HEADED BY HUGH MACMILLAN, (AN EVENT ORCHESTRATED BY MACMILLAN'S FRIEND, WAYLAND DREW) GOT OFF COURSE, ON LAKE MUSKOKA, (RAN INTO A HEAVY WIND COMING UP STREAM) DURING THE RE-ENACTMENT OF DAVID THOMPSON'S HISTORIC EXPLORATION, OF THE MUSKOKA WATERSHED, PART OF AN EVENT SPONSORED BY THE BRACEBRIDGE HISTORICAL SOCIETY, IN THE EARLY 1980'S, AT BRACEBRIDGE BAY PARK. IF MEMORY SERVES, BRUCE WAS ONE OF THE MEMBERS OF MR. MACMILLAN'S RE-ENACTMENT PARTY. ALL THE CANOES ARRIVED SAFELY, ALTHOUGH AN HOUR OR SO LATE, AND A PARTY WAS HELD TO CELEBRATE THEIR SAFE ARRIVAL. IT GAVE US A LOT TO KID ABOUT, AS HUGH MACMILLAN WAS A PERFECTIONIST IN EVERY WAY. IN A FINAL CALL FROM HUGH MACMILLAN, BEFORE HE PASSED AWAY SEVERAL YEARS AGO, HE ASKED ME TO TOUCH BASE WITH HIS OLD FRIEND BRUCE MCPHAIL; AND SO I DID. WE ALL HAD A LOVE FOR HISTORY AND CANOES IN COMMON.
     BRACEBRIDGE HAS LOST TWO OF ITS BIGGEST SUPPORTERS, AND FINE CITIZENS.



HISTORY HAS ITS NOSTALGIC, ROMANTIC, CHARMING SIDE; MIXED IN WITH ITS HARD, UNYIELDING REALITIES

A MEMORIAL TRIBUTE TO MUSKOKA HISTORIAN, CECIL PORTER

     When Muskoka, lost historian, Robert Boyer, it was a serious loss to our profession, quite limited in number, here in the southern climes, of our region of Ontario. We need all hands on deck, because the job of recording our history isn't done yet. So with news this week, about the lost of Cecil Porter, the surviving historians, once again, understand, that this will have a big impact on available personnel, to finish up what we began a long time ago. When we look behind us, we realize how few historian apprentices, are following behind. What should be the case, and may hopefully yet transpire, is that fellow citizens will come to be inspired by the work of these fine chaps, who are imprinted as the authors of many first-rate histories penned for, and about this region. Both men, and Civil War historian, Tom Brooks, who also passed away recently, were, in their own way, beacons for the study of the past. They were role models, by all definition, but was anyone else, other than associate historians, watching and learning, from their meticulous work in respective fields?
     We are losing some of our most important local historians. First it was the sudden death of Civil War historian, Tom Brooks, a well known re-enactor, who appeared in the movie, "Gettysburg," and most recently, it was our colleague, Cecil Porter
     I never knew whether Gravenhurst, and Muskoka regional historian, Cecil Porter liked me, or even approved of my work in the field of local history. I heard through the grapevine once, from a friend of a friend, that Cecil tolerated my efforts, to expose the social, cultural history of Muskoka; and honestly, that was kind of an honor. He didn't bestow honors casually, or regularly, so just getting a nod and not a shake of the head, was approval worth waiting for.
     When I read that Cecil Porter had passed away this week, I sat for a long time thinking back over the past week. As a matter or considerable irony, it was only last week, that I was working through his outstanding book, on the history of Camp 20, here in Gravenhurst, entitled "The Gilded Cage." It is the well researched and written account of the German Prisoner of War Camp, that the federal government established, from 1940 to 1946, to accommodate a large and dangerous population of Adolf Hitler's military personnel, captured, and removed for safety reasons, from Europe, to high security camps in Canada. It is one of the most important books of all the Muskoka regional histories published, in part, (and in my own opinion), because it is a subject few wanted to tackle. The town is so concerned about its political correctness, that to this day, years after the book's publication, you will still not be able to find any federal, or provincial heritage marker, identifying the property's former use. Cecil Porter knew the importance of having an historical record of the town's service to the Commonwealth, during the war years, and went ahead and produced an award winning book. It didn't get an award, but it should have, especially from the Town of Gravenhurst.
     Cecil used to visit me, back in the early 1990's, when we had our former antique shop, on Manitoba Street, in Bracebridge. We'd talk about Muskoka books that had been published, and about ones that should be researched and written, sometime in the future. He knew about writing books, and I knew about publishing them. I had, afterall, been employed by The Herald-Gazette, previous to this, a firm that had published many of Muskoka's well known histories. We shared information whenever we met, and promised to keep digging for more good stories.
    I never once saw or heard Cecil laugh, but it's not because he didn't have a sense of humor. In our discussions, his words were few, and most of them were for the purpose of crafting questions. He was interested in my perspective, as a largely Bracebridge historian, in those days, but he was sly and would occasionally try to trip me up, knowing the answer before he asked the question. He wore his little toque so perfectly, it almost seemed as if had grown on his head; and there were times, when what we had been discussing, seemed as if we had actually come to a confluence, where we actually had some common borders. Meaning, it would have only taken a small plank bridge to span the thin divide; instead of, when we first met, when in professional terms, any successful bridging would have to been measured in miles. He was a teacher of considerable acclaim, but he didn't offer to be either my tutor or mentor. He did serve himself up as a colleague, and that was both an honor and privilege.
    If you knew Cecil, especially as an historian, you came to respect that his passion was deeply imbedded in his seemingly shy, reserved personality; and he didn't show his trump cards to just any one. I always knew he was holding trump cards, by the tell tale twinkle of his eyes in conversation, and the way he'd look away, momentarily and ponder, whether he should share or not! But he wasn't going to succumb to my questioning without certain rules of engagement. He had his pet projects, Camp Calydor being one of them, and I think he suspected I was the kind of character who might borrow information for my own advantage. I'm the same, so we were, in a way, unlikely kindred spirits. Always a little suspicious of the competition. What was important to me, for the years that I knew him, was his interest in fact finding. When he got turned on to something, he was about as dogged to ferret out the truth, as any historian I have ever known; yet he worked quietly on his own, and showed little emotion, except maybe annoyance, when something or other couldn't be resolved.
     When I worked on a pet project, regarding the naming of Gravenhurst, back in the late 1990's, I had taken the controversial step, of challenging every Bracebridge historian of the past, who had in some way, repeated in error, that Washington Irving had somehow been connected to William Dawson LeSueur's, selection of names, for the first post office. I had already wrestled with my own mentor, Bob Boyer, about the falsehoods connected to the naming, which he had played a limited but perpetual role, and then having to approach Gravenhurst historians, with another bit of research information, that would remove an impasse, but create a stir at the same time.    You see, I had finally, with help of Irving scholars, in the United States, and related sleuthing at home, been able to prove beyond doubt, that Gravenhurst had not been named after reference in the book "Bracebridge Hall," as historians to the north had been wrongly claiming for decades. While it's true, that Bracebridge was named after Irving's book, "Bracebridge Hall," by LeSueur, a federal postal authority at the time, it came two years after the post office was granted in Gravenhurst (1862). That was my first hard fact, that didn't seem right, having some background information on Dr. LeSueur. He wouldn't have searched through the text, to find the name "Gravenhurst," so he could attach it to the sign out front, of the new hamlet post office. And, it would have made more sense, to use the name "Bracebridge" to rename what had been known as "McCabe's Landing. Afterall, it took two more years before Bracebridge was even named. So the claims Gravenhurst had anything at all to do with Washington Irving, had been successfully refuted, and I had been led this way by Cecil Porter, because of a reference in the town's Centennial history, "The Light of Other Days." The reference noted the possibility, LeSueur had instead, borrowed the title "Gravenhurst," from a book written by British poet / philosopher, William Henry Smith. Yet there was still the overhanging potential, that the Bracebridge historians were correct, in assuming Irving, had also made reference to a place called Gravenhurst somewhere in the text of "Bracebridge Hall."
     So I sent off a request to Washington Irving scholars, and asked for their assistance, as to whether the author had ever used this name in any of his many books. The answer was what I had suspected. No! To follow up, I purchased a copy of "Bracebridge Hall," and read it myself first, without finding the name, and then I handed it off to Cecil, for a read-through, and alas, we had unfettered the town from a century's old error, regarding the naming of our community. The fact is, Cecil and the book committee, responsible for "The Light of Other Days," had been correct, in the first place, to have named Smith's book as a potential source of the town's name; even though it took some grunt work to resolve it before the turn of this new century.
    I think this marked the occasion, when Cecil and I were closest, at least in our professional ideals, although he always let me know, that as far as our relationship, I would always be the aspiring underling. He wasn't rude about it, but he was stubbornly territorial. The next occasion, I worked closely with Cecil, was one of those happenstance moments, when history arrives in all its subtle glory, without warning, and you hope the bridge can be built in time, to avoid imminent disaster. Suzanne and I were attending a Gravenhurst auction, for a well known family with church and municipal connections, and when poking through the estate items, we uncovered several jammed to overflowing boxes, of historical documents, all pertaining to the community. At the time, there were a dozen major collectors, I detected in the crowd, and one in particular, who I knew would bid this significant collection into the wild blue yonder. We knew that the town's archive's committee would want this material, and I realized we didn't have enough money that day, to ensure these records stayed in Gravenhurst. We sent messages out with every one we could find, who knew Cecil, and thank goodness, he was close at hand that morning. He rushed over to the sale, and we had to pull the boxes away from some of the collectors, who had spotted them under the tables. To shorten this story, we knew that as municipal records, these were not to be sold. Rightfully, they belonged to Gravenhurst, and should have been returned many years earlier, by members of the subject family. We had legal advice in-person, from a provincial civil servant, from Queen's Park, who happened to be at the sale, overhearing the conundrum; who added her authority, that the documents should be withdrawn from the auction. She went with us, Suzanne, myself and Cecil, to convince Peter Green, a Gravenhurst auctioneer, to remove the boxes from the auction listing. Peter, a long time associate, was willing to hear the appeal, and agreed, that they were sensitive heritage documents, from the municipality, that should remain in the local archives. What a morning it was, but honestly, it was I believe, the first time I saw Cecil smile ear to ear. If those boxes had gone for sale, there was enough fire power that morning, to have elevated the bid to over a thousand dollars, for the collection of documents. The archives didn't have that money to spend, and even if we'd pooled all our money, in our possession, we would have had a hard time out-bidding the collectors with deep pockets.
     Cecil and I talked casually about local heritage matters, four or five times a year, ever since our first meeting, in our Bracebridge antique shop. He was a witty, but intense chap, who immersed himself in local heritage, partly as a hobby, partly as a commitment to his inner sleuth; because he really enjoyed any opportunity, to reveal more a bout the past, than was currently available. He did that with his book "The Gilded Cage," which I guarantee, will be an even more important book in the future, as citizens of our region gradually come to recognize, just how remarkable it was, that we had a German Prisoner of War camp in our backyard. He showed a lot of courage putting that book together, and to date, it is still a seriously under appreciated history.
     Suzanne and I were both shocked to read about his passing, from Mark Clairmont's online publication, "Muskoka To-daily." Mark, an old family friend, wrote a great editorial piece about Cecil, with a lot more biographical information included. Take a look at it if you get a chance.
     We've lost a fine citizen this week, and I've lost a sparring partner; in history that is!


ARE HISTORIANS BORN THIS WAY; OR ARRIVE BY WAY OF A STRANGE METEMORPHISIS

     My mother always thought I was different from the rest of my classmates. I sort of think she thought I'd grow out of my interest in old things and antiquated places. She knew that I used sneak into an old house, on Torrance Avenue, in Burlington, and right up to the night before it was pummeled, to dust, by a wrecking ball, I had been wandering cheerfully through its debris-strewn halls. I have never really understood, what has compelled me to visit old homesteads, and vacant buildings from another era; just that they possessed something I needed in my life. I never once thought about what it all meant, other than it did influence me to delve into the antique profession; a pre-occupation, you see, that allowed me to handle and possess relics of the past. I still wasn't entirely happy, especially having watched that beautiful old Burlington estate, come crashing down, with all its memories, like ghosts, trapped in time. I really felt bad that day, as if the presence I sensed, and appreciated, as the occupant of that century old house, had been lost. I felt like this a lot, because I was always on the look-out for opportunities, associated with abandoned cabins and houses. I always found something mysterious, and alluring, in these relics of architecture, and felt sad, by the fact they had been abandoned in the first place.
     I felt this way about the Bird House, in Bracebridge, in the late 1970's. It was known formally as Woodchester Villa, the octagonal former home of Bird's Woollen Mill founder, Henry Bird, that was in great need of restoration. So sensing this was a house with spirits that had to be saved, I made it a project to raise community interest, with a plan to purchase the beautiful estate, on the hillside, overlooking the Muskoka River; to restore it for a future museum. Well, that came about, the result of a huge citizen effort, and the kindness of the Rotary Club and the Town of Bracebridge. It was great, let me tell you, to walk through the porch door, and then the front entrance of that grand house, and feel what I sensed, was a good, comfortable feeling, of a contented family home. I will always have a problem trying to explain this feeling about old buildings, but for many of you reading this, it will jive with sensations you've experienced in life; visiting some place and having the feeling the house possessed a little extra character, and this doesn't mean ghosts as such. It's just a feeling, that the memories here, are animated and spirited. There's a story within, and it wants out. The visitor, me, seemed to be the conduit, but I never minded the extra duty. I was comfortable with this history thing, through and through, just as I am today; although I confess to staying out of abandoned houses.
     So to better explain, here are some archives notes, about a few of these associations, I enjoyed, but could never really justify as far as an explanation, "why?"

From the Bracebridge Archives


LOVING HISTORY, ANTIQUES AND A FORMER WAY OF LIFE - WOODCHESTER VILLA WAS A DREAM JOB

WE ALL WANTED SATISFIED VISITORS - WE HOPED THEY WOULD COME BACK

I WAS A BAD, BAD BOY. WHAT DO YOU EXPECT FROM A FELLOW WHO WAS ONCE KICKED OUT OF CUBS FOR INSUBORDINATION? I ASKED THE LEADER TO REIMBURSE MY MOTHER FOR A NEW SHIRT, THAT HAD JUST THEN BEEN RIPPED APART, WHILE PLAYING BRITISH BULLDOG AT THE OLD SCOUT HALL, ACROSS FROM THE BRACEBRIDGE TRAIN STATION. WHEN HE SAID IT WASN'T HIS FAULT THAT ANOTHER CUB HAD RUINED MY NEW SHIRT, I INFORMED HIM OF HIS RESPONSIBILITIES AS A CUB LEADER, TO CONTROL HIS TROOP'S BEHAVIOR. SO HE SHOWED ME THE DOOR. SO IT HAS BEEN A LIFE-LONG TRAIT OF MINE, TO CHALLENGE AUTHORITY.
I DID IT AS A DIRECTOR OF THE BRACEBRIDGE HISTORICAL SOCIETY, AND THEN MANAGER OF THE SITE BACK IN THE 1980'S. I WAS SO ENTHRALLED WITH THE "BIRD HOUSE," AS IT WAS KNOWN THEN, BECAUSE OF THE BIRD FAMILY CONNECTION, THAT I WOULD CONDUCT COMPLETE TOURS OF THE HOUSE WITH STUDENT GROUPS. WHY I BECAME A HISTORICAL SOCIETY BAD BOY, WAS DUE TO MY PENCHANT FOR DEFYING THE BOARD AND THE TOWN ITSELF, BY ALLOWING STUDENTS AND OTHER GUESTS TO VISIT THE WIDOW'S WALK AT THE VERY TOP OF THE OCTAGONAL HOUSE. WHILE IT WASN'T FORBIDDEN, AND I NEVER ONCE HAD A FORMAL, WRITTEN DECREE, FROM TOWN, IN MY HAND, IT WAS GENERALLY ACCEPTED THE ROOFTOP RAILING WAS UNSAFE. THIS WASN'T THE CASE. IT WAS MORE THE SECURELY REINFORCED, OR I NEVER WOULD HAVE ALLOWED ITS USE. IT WAS CLEARLY THE MOST IMPORTANT PART OF THE WOODCHESTER EXPERIENCE. I FELT I HAD TO USE IT, AND I WAS WELL AWARE OF THE CONSEQUENCES. HERE'S WHY I DID IT?
FROM MY EARLIEST WORK IN THE MUSEUM, AND AS A VOLUNTEER TOUR GUIDE, THE WIDOW'S WALK WAS FOR SMALL TOURS, AND IT WAS ALWAYS DISCRETIONARY. IF WE HAD A RAMBUNCTIOUS SCHOOL GROUP, FOR EXAMPLE, I MIGHT DECIDE THE RISK WASN'T WORTH THE EXTRA EFFORT. I HATED DOING THIS, BECAUSE A TRIP TO THE TOP OF THE HOUSE, TO OVERLOOK THE MUSKOKA RIVER, AND THE HISTORIC DOWNTOWN, WAS AN AMAZING EXPERIENCE…..THAT FRANKLY MADE THE TRIP TO WOODCHESTER, FAR MORE MEMORABLE, THAN JUST THE BASIC THREE FLOOR TOUR, AND THEN OVER TO THE MUSEUM ANNEX. ONE DAY, SOMEONE FROM THE HISTORICAL SOCIETY, ON ADVICE FROM SOME TOWN OFFICIAL, ASKED STAFF AND VOLUNTEERS TO CEASE TAKING VISITORS TO THE ATTIC OF THE HOUSE, WHICH OF COURSE LED TO THE STEEP LADDER TO THE ROOF-HATCHWAY. SAFETY WAS THE CONCERN, BUT IT WASN'T BASED THEN, ON ANY SERIOUS DETERIORATION OF THE RAILING, THE WIDOW'S WALK PLATFORM, OR THE STAIRS FROM THE ATTIC. IT WASN'T BASED ON ANYTHING MORE THAN THE FEAR OF SOMETHING BAD HAPPENING. WELL, THERE WAS POTENTIAL FOR THAT IN A HUNDRED OTHER LOCATIONS, IN THE MUSEUM AND AROUND THE TREED PROPERTY. I JUST COULDN'T SHORT-CHANGE THE INTEGRITY OF THIS OCTAGONAL WONDER OF THE 1880'S. I FELT IT WAS WORTH THE RISK, USING IT ON SPECIAL OCCASIONS. I COULD TAKE SMALL GROUPS, OF TWO PEOPLE PLUS MYSELF, UP TO THE ROOF PEAK, TO ENJOY THE GREAT VIEW. NEVER LOST A SINGLE SOUL. BUT I MAY HAVE INSPIRED A FEW.
IT'S CERTAINLY TRUE I COULD HAVE BEEN IN SERIOUS TROUBLE IF ANY ONE HAD TOPPLED OVER THAT RAILING. IF I HAD ACTUALLY SURVIVED THE FALL, THAT IS! YOU SEE, I HUNG ONTO EVERYONE WHO VENTURED ONTO THAT ROOF, SUCH THAT IF THEY FELL, SO DID I. MALE OR FEMALE, BOY OR GIRL, I TOLD THESE FOLKS IN ADVANCE, MY HANDS WERE GOING TO BE ALL OVER THEM……SO DON'T BE SURPRISED IF THE TOUR GUIDE GETS FAMILIAR. EVEN IN THE ATTIC AREA OF THE HOUSE, WHERE THERE WERE SECRET WALL COMPARTMENTS AROUND THE OUTSIDE EDGE, I WAS GUILTY OF ALLOWING FOLKS TO HAVE A WEE GANDER AT THE DETAILED (EXPOSED) CONSTRUCTION OF AN OCTAGONAL HOUSE. OF COURSE, ONE OF THE OTHER PROBLEM AREAS, WAS THAT THE BOARD HAD ALSO DECIDED, THE VERY NARROW STAIRCASE FROM THE SECOND FLOOR TO THE ATTIC, WAS ALSO TOO STEP TO NAVIGATE. I DISAGREED. IT WAS THE DESIGN OF THE TIME, AND A RARITY VISITORS NEEDED TO SEE, IN ORDER TO UNDERSTAND LIVING CONDITIONS IN SUCH AN ODDLY DESIGNED HOUSE. I ONLY ALLOWED SEVERAL GUESTS TO CLIMB WITH ME TO THE ATTIC ROOM, AND THEN WE HANDLED A SLOW, CAREFUL HIKE UP TO THE WIDOW'S WALK. SAFETY WAS ALWAYS MY CONCERN, AND THIS WENT FOR MY OWN FAMILY MEMBERS CLIMBING THOSE STAIRS ALMOST DAILY.
ON MORE THAN A FEW OCCASIONS, I'D HAVE TO DUCK BACK THROUGH THE HATCH, WHEN A PERSNICKETY DIRECTOR WOULD SHOW UP UNANNOUNCED, BUT MY GUESTS WERE ALWAYS GOOD SPORTS ABOUT IT……AND FELT PRIVILEGED THAT THE GUY WHO HELP COMMENCE THE MUSEUM PROJECT IN THE FIRST PLACE, WAS GIVING SUCH A PERSONAL TOUR, INTO FORBIDDEN NOOKS AND CRANNIES. MY WIFE AND I DID A LARGE NUMBER OF SPECIAL TOURS, DURING THE OFF-SEASON, AND FOR SCHOOL AND BUS TOURS, SPECIAL DELEGATIONS, VISITING DIGNITARIES, POLITICIANS, FILM COMPANIES, AND FOR THE NATIONAL MEDIA. WE ATTRACTED QUITE A NUMBER OF JOURNALISTS BACK THEN, FASCINATED BY THE OCTAGONAL DESIGN. AS WELL, THERE WERE QUITE A FEW TRAVEL WRITERS WHO'D SHOW-UP, OFTEN UNANNOUNCED, AND TO KEEP THE PRESS "POSITIVE" ABOUT OUR SITE, WE HAD AN EMERGENCY DRILL TO STAFF THE MUSEUM WITH VOLUNTEERS. I WOULD OFTEN GET A CALL FROM A STAFF MEMBER, LETTING ME KNOW ABOUT A TRAVEL WRITER SHOWING UP, AND IT WOULD TAKE ME ABOUT FIVE MINUTES TO DASH FROM THE HERALD-GAZETTE OFFICE, ON DOMINION STREET, TO THE TOP OF THAT HISTORIC HILL. AND OF COURSE, THESE SPECIAL GUESTS TOOK A WALK ON THE WILD SIDE, AND VISITED THE FAMED WIDOW'S WALK, WHERE THE LADIES OF THE BIRD FAMILY OFTEN SAT, TO ENJOY THEIR AFTERNOON TEA. IT WAS THE ONE ASPECT OF THE TOUR, THAT SEALED THE DEAL. FOLKS ADMITTED IT WAS THE HIGHLIGHT OF WHAT WAS OTHERWISE JUST AN ORDINARY TOUR OF A VICTORIAN ERA HOUSE. OF COURSE WE MIGHT HAVE MENTIONED ITS RESIDENT SPIRITS, WHICH DID GET A LITTLE PRESS BACK IN THE EARLY EIGHTIES. GHOST STORIES AND MUSEUMS…..THEY JUST SEEM TO WORK SO WELL TOGETHER.
THE REAL NUTS AND BOLTS OF THE WOODCHESTER DILEMMA, HAD EVERYTHING TO DO WITH THE MUSEUM'S PUBLIC ACCEPTANCE. IT'S POPULARITY, AS PERCEIVED BY TOWN HALL. AS IT HAD LONG BEEN A STRUGGLE TO CREATE THE KIND OF INTEREST, THAT MADE BEGGING FOR MONEY SOMEWHAT EASIER. I THOUGHT THAT IF I COULD PRODUCE ENOUGH CUSTOMER SATISFACTION, AND BOTH TESTIMONIALS AND SOME MAJOR NEWSPAPER HEADLINES, ENDORSING THE PLACE, TOWN COUNCILLORS MIGHT LOOK MORE FAVORABLY ON THE SITE. NO MATTER WHAT WE DID, OR HOW MANY ACCOLADES WE RECEIVED, IT NEVER REALLY CHANGED THE LAGGING GENERAL OPINION, SUCH THAT IT WOULD INSPIRE MERIT INCREASES TO FUNDING. IT WAS A FAILED DREAM OF MINE, TO HAVE ALL OF BRACEBRIDGE'S COUNCILLORS COME FOR A VISIT. SO THAT WE COULD REGALE THEM WITH TRIPS UP TO THE WIDOW'S WALK, AND LET THEM SEE, FIRST-HAND, THE LARGE CROWDS THAT USED TO COME FOR STRAWBERRY AND BLUEBERRY SOCIALS, AND THE POPULAR "CHRISTMAS IN JULY" WEEK OF PROGRAMS. ACTIVITIES FOR THE WHOLE FAMILY. BUT OUTSIDE OF THE PRESS COMING FOR SOME FILL PHOTOGRAPHS FOR THEIR SUMMER PAPERS, THE POSITIVES OF THE MUSUEM DID NOT MAKE IT TO THE COUNCIL TABLE. THIS IS NOT TO SAY WE DIDN'T HAVE SUPPORT FROM CERTAIN COUNCILLORS. JUST NOT ENOUGH TO CONVINCE TOWN HALL GENERALLY, WE WERE A THRIVING COMMUNITY ASSET OF CULTURE AND HISTORY. NO MATTER WHAT WE DID, ALL OF IT FINANCED ON A SHOE-STRING BUDGET, NOTHING COULD ELEVATE US FROM NUISANCE STATUS…..AND THIS GOES BACK TO THE START-UP OF THE RESTORATION PROJECT. WHAT SEEMED MORE THAN JUST A GLIMMER OF INTEREST, WAS JUST FOOL'S GOLD TO THE HISTORICAL SOCIETY. COUNCILLORS WOULD SMILE FOR THE CAMERA, WHEN ATTENDING SOMETHING HERITAGE RELATED, LIKE ONE OF THE HUGE EMPIRE DINNERS, PUT ON BY THE HISTORICAL SOCIETY, BUT NOT MUCH MORE. IT WASN'T A PRIORITY FROM DAY ONE. IT WOULDN'T HAVE REQUIRED A CLAIRVOYANT TO PREDICT THE FUTURE, WHICH WAS WITHIN A HAIR'S BREADTH OF FLAT-LINING FROM THE EARLY 1980'S. WHICH BRINGS US TO THE PRESENT MISFORTUNE FACING A WONDERFUL LITTLE HILLSIDE MUSEUM……THAT HAD, OH SO MUCH POTENTIAL…..BUT OH SO LITTLE MONEY, TO FULFILL ITS POTENTIAL.

THE TRULY CRITICAL RESULT OF THIS GENERAL DISINTEREST FROM THE MUNICIPALITY, AND THE ONGOING SHORTAGE OF MONEY, WAS THAT VOLUNTEERS JUST GAVE UP ON TRYING TO CHANGE PERCEPTION. IT WAS WORK ON TOP OF WORK, AND IT BECAME A JOY-LESS WAY TO SPEND TIME. WHEN I APPROACHED MUSKOKA ARTS AND CRAFTS MEMBER, JAMIE SHERMAN, IN THE LATE 1980'S, ASKING IF THE ASSOCIATION MIGHT BE INTERESTED IN SHARING A PROPERTY WITH THE HISTORICAL SOCIETY, IT WAS WITH THIS SENSE OF THE INEVITABLE……THAT WE EITHER FIND A WAY TO REDUCE OUR EXPENSES AND RESPONSIBILITIES ON THAT HILLSIDE, OR FACE IMMINENT CLOSURE. NEGOTIATIONS WITH MUSKOKA ARTS AND CRAFTS WENT WELL, AND THEY WOULD EVENTUALLY TAKE-OVER THE MUSEUM ANNEX (ON THE SITE OF A FORMER 1800'S CHURCH), AND CALL IT THE CHAPEL GALLERY. IT COST ME DEARLY IN SO MANY WAYS, BECAUSE MUSEUM PURISTS WERE OUTRAGED THAT I HAD INITIATED THIS DOUBLING-UP OF PROPERTY USE…..AND WATERED DOWN THE WHOLE HISTORIC ATMOSPHERE OF THE PROPERTY. I SAW IT AS A WAY OF MERGING ART AND HISTORY, CULTURE AND RECREATION, ON A TRULY BEAUTIFUL PIECE OF URBAN LANDSCAPE. I SAW IT AS A MEANS OF BRINGING MORE PEOPLE ANNUALLY, TO THE OFTEN FORGOTTEN HILLSIDE. I SAW THE ART GALLERY, AND MUSKOKA ARTS AND CRAFTS GENERALLY, BECOMING BIGGER PARTNERS ON-SITE, AND I THINK THIS IS WHAT HAS HAPPENED TO A DEGREE. I'VE ALWAYS BEEN HAPPY ABOUT THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE GALLERY. THE OTHER OPTION WAS TO PLYWOOD-UP BOTH BUILDINGS, AND WALK AWAY WITH HEAD LOWERED.
I HAD ALWAYS WANTED TO BE PRESIDENT OF THE HISTORICAL SOCIETY, FROM ITS FOUNDING. MY FIRST POST, UNDER PRESIDENT WAYLAND DREW, WAS AS RECORDING SECRETARY. FROM THEN ON, I'D BEEN AN ON-AGAIN, OFF-AGAIN DIRECTOR, DUE TO THE FACT I WAS WORKING OUT OF TOWN. I REMEMBER AT ONE SOCIETY MEETING, HELD AT BRACEBRIDGE PUBLIC SCHOOL, I BELIEVE, BEING NOMINATED AS PRESIDENT. EVEN MY WIFE, ALSO A DIRECTOR, PUT HER HAND UP, AND ALTHOUGH FLATTERED TO PIECES, I WASN'T UNDER ANY ILLUSION ABOUT THE ROUGH PASSAGE AHEAD. THE MUSUEM HAD ALREADY COME IN CONTACT WITH THE ICE-BERG. SO WHEN THE DIRECTORS CAST THEIR VOTES,……AND THERE WAS ONLY ONE CANDIDATE BY THE WAY, WELL, I GOT MY CHAIN OF OFFICE ALRIGHT. IT WAS ATTACHED TO A PONDEROUSLY LARGE ANCHOR. THE OFFICIAL TRANSFER OF POWER INVOLVED THE PAST PRESIDENT, UNCEREMONIOUSLY SLIDING THE BOX OF WOODCHESTER DOCUMENTS, LIKE A CASE OF BEER ON A TRACK, DOWN THE LONG TABLE TO WHERE I WAS SITTING. NOT QUITE WHAT I HAD FANTASIZED ABOUT. IT DIDN'T EVEN TAKE "READING THROUGH THE LINES," TO APPRECIATE THAT THE MESSAGE ATTACHED WAS "GOOD RIDDANCE." SO I STARTED OFF WITH THE AUDIBLE WHISPER OF A WORD THAT SOUNDED A LOT LIKE "SUCKER."
SO PUT YOURSELF IN THE PRESIDENT'S SHOES. WHEN THE BURGLAR ALARM WOULD GO OFF, USUALLY AT 2 A.M., IT WAS MY JOB TO MEET THE ONTARIO PROVINCIAL POLICE, ON SITE, TO CONDUCT A ROOM TO ROOM SEARCH. FORTUNATELY, ON NUMEROUS OF THESE OCCASIONS, THE OFFICER WOULD BE CONSTABLE ED KOWALSKY, ONE OF MY HOCKEY CLUB TEAM-MATES, AND WE TOOK A MORE LIGHT-HEARTED APPROACH TO THE INVESTIGATION. THEY WERE ALL FALSE ALARMS. BUT WHEN ANOTHER OFFICER WOULD HAVE TO ATTEND, THE SEARCHES WERE A LITTLE LESS ENTHUSIASTIC. SOMETIMES IT HAPPENED SEVERAL NIGHTS A WEEK. SEEING AS I LIVED QUITE A DISTANCE OUT OF TOWN, THESE EARLY MORNING SITE INSPECTIONS WERE BECOMING QUITE DISRUPTIVE. ESPECIALLY FOR OUR WEE LADS, WHO HAD A HARD TIME GETTING BACK TO SLEEP, THINKING ABOUT DAD TRACKING BAD GUYS, WHO HAD APPARENTLY BROKEN INTO THE MUSEUM. EACH TIME, I WOULD OFFER MY SINCERE APOLOGY TO THE OPP, AND VOW TO GET THE ALARM RE-ADJUSTED.
AFTER ABOUT A YEAR OF THIS NONSENSE, WE FINALLY FOUND OUT THE CAUSE OF THE FALSE ALARMS. THE WIRING OF THE ALARM ITSELF, THROUGH THE ATTIC, WAS ATTRACTIVE TO SEVERAL RESIDENT SQUIRRELS. IT SEEMS THE COATING ON THE WIRE, TASTED LIKE LICORICE TO THEM. SO THEY HAD STRIPPED SUBSTANTIAL AREAS OF COATING, AND EACH TIME THEY HAD A TREAT, THE ALARM WENT OFF. THEY LIKED POST MIDNIGHT SNACKS. THIS WAS THE LIFE OF THE PRESIDENT, AND FIRST LADY.
I LIKED TO STIR THINGS UP THEN, MUCH AS I DO NOW. SO WHEN WE HIRED A CURATORIAL DUO, TO TAKE OVER THE DAY-TO-DAY OPERATIONS, DURING THE SUMMER MONTHS, I HAD NO IDEA IT INVOLVED A CANON. A SMALL ONE. NOT LIKE A FORT HENRY, OR GETTYSBURG CANON, BUT A CANON NONE THE LESS. ONE DAY I STEPPED OUTSIDE THE NEWSPAPER OFFICE, ON DOMINION STREET, IN TIME TO HEAR A LOUD REPORT…..AS IF A SUBSTANTIAL GUN HAD BEEN FIRED SOMEWHERE CLOSE-BY. I ALSO NOTICED, BY MY WATCH, THAT IT WAS 1 P.M. IT WAS AN OLD REPORTER'S HABIT, TO TIME STRANGE, OR OUT-OF-PLACE EVENTS, IN CASE I WOULD HAVE TO WRITE ABOUT IT LATER. I DIDN'T HEAR ANY AMBULANCE SIRENS, AND THERE WAS NOTHING GOING ON AT THE FIRE HALL, SO I WENT BACK INTO THE OFFICE. THEN THE PHONES BEGAN TO RING. YUP, THOSE CALLS WEREN'T FOR THE EDITOR OF THE HERALD-GAZETTE. THEY WERE FOR SOMEONE, ANYONE FROM THE MUSEUM, WHO COULD EXPLAIN WHY THERE WAS CANON-FIRE COMING FROM THE HILLSIDE. GEEZ, HAD THOSE PESKY AMERICANS INVADED US AGAIN? AS I HAD KIN IN THE WAR OF 1812, I WAS READY TO DEFEND CANADA ONCE MORE.
WHEN I DROVE UP THE LANE TO WOODCHESTER VILLA, I COULD SEE MY CURATORIAL STAFF, STANDING BESIDE A TINY IRON CANON ON WHEELS, PARKED ON THE SIDE LAWN. IT WAS EXPLAINED TO ME, THAT THE STAFFER PLANNED ON FIRING THE CANON EVERY DAY OF THE WEEK, AT PRECISELY I:00 P.M., SO THAT TOWN FOLKS COULD RE-SET THEIR CLOCKS TO THE ACCURATE TIME OF THE DAY. MEANWHILE NEIGHBORS ARE LOOKING ON, AS IF THERE WAS GOING TO BE RETURN FIRE FROM SOME UNIDENTIFIED MILITIA , CLIMBING UP FROM THE VALLEY BELOW. I DID KNOW ABOUT THE CANON BEFORE THIS, BECAUSE IT HAD BEEN USED EARLIER THAT WEEK, AT A SPECIAL HERITAGE PLAQUE UNVEILING AT WOODCHESTER. I DIDN'T THINK IT WAS GOING TO BECOME A REGULAR THING. IT WAS AN INTERESTING SITUATION, AND VISITORS TO THE MUSUEM SEEMED AMUSED. THE KIDS LIKED TO WATCH THE PREPARATION, AND FIRING, LIKE THEY WOULD AT FORT YORK, SO I TRIED TO PACIFY THE NEIGHBORS THAT THEY WEREN'T IN ANY IMMINENT DANGER…..AND AS A BONUS, THEY COULD GET THE ACCURATE TIME EACH DAY.
WORKING AT WOODCHESTER VILLA WAS ALWAYS AN UNPREDICTABLE VENTURE. WHEN PLAYING HOST TO THE GENERAL PUBLIC, YOU HAD TO BE EVER WATCHFUL. FROM PREVENTING ICE CREAM CONES BEING TAKEN IN THE HOUSE, TO DISALLOWING PIANO SMASHING IN THE VICTORIAN PARLOR. QUITE A FEW PARENTS, AS I REMEMBER, USED TO LET THEIR KIDS RUN, AS SOON AS THEY HIT THE FRINGE OF THE PROPERTY, AND IT CARRIED ON, INTO BOTH MUSEUM BUILDINGS. IT WAS HIGH STRESS, BECAUSE THERE WERE A LOT OF VALUABLE ANTIQUES IN THE HOUSE, ESPECIALLY, THAT COULD BE DAMAGED BY ROUGH-HOUSING. LARGE CAMP AND SCHOOL TOURS EXHAUSTED STAFF, AND NO MATTER HOW CLOSELY WE WATCHED, THERE WAS ALWAYS SOME TYPE OF DAMAGE, AND YES…..TOPPLED ICE CREAM ON A RUG, OR ON A VINTAGE TABLE CLOTH.
THE BIGGEST DISASTER I EVER ENCOUNTERED, DURING MY TENURE, WAS WHEN SOME STAFFER HAD DECIDED TO PLACE A BIRD FAMILY WEDDING DRESS, FROM THE VICTORIAN VINTAGE, ON A BED IN THE MASTER BEDROOM. IT WAS SECURELY ROPED OFF, FROM VISITORS, BUT NOT FROM THE DEVASTATION THAT CAN HAPPEN WHEN THE HEATING SYSTEM EXPLODES, WITH WHAT I UNDERSTOOD WAS A "SOOT BLOW-BACK," WHICH I HAD NEVER EXPERIENCED PREVIOUSLY……OR WOULD LIKE TO AGAIN. NOW IMAGINE, IF YOU CAN, THE LARGE AMOUNT OF LACE ON A DRESS LIKE THIS. WHAT WAS WHITE BECAME BLACK. THROUGHOUT THE HOUSE. THE DRESS HAD TO BE SHIPPED TO A MUSEUM CONSERVATOR, IN OTTAWA, FOR RESTORATION. EXPENSIVE. YES IT WAS. DID WE HAVE MONEY TO COVER THE CLEAN UP? NO WE DIDN'T. WE JUST HAD TO DRAIN ONE RESOURCE TO OFFSET THE DEMANDS OF ANOTHER. WE HADN'T CREATED AN EMERGENCY FUND, IN OUR ANNUAL OPERATING BUDGETS, AS SHOULD HAVE OCCURRED FROM THE BEGINNING, EXPECTING SITUATIONS TO HAPPEN WELL IN ADVANCE. WE JUST KEPT FALLING FURTHER AND FURTHER BEHIND IN THIS REGARD. WE COULD HAVE BEEN FUNDRAISING EVERY MONTH OF THE YEAR AND STILL FALLEN SHORT OF NEEDED FUNDS.
IT'S CERTAINLY SOMETHING TO THINK ABOUT, AT THIS TIME IN THE MUSEUM'S HISTORY……AND IN THIS ERA OF AUSTERITY….. WHETHER THE RESTORATION COSTS AND THE DAY TO DAY EXPENSES, COULD EVER BE RECOVERED BY OPERATION REVENUE. I AM A PAGE FROM THE PAST, AND I HAVE TO BE HONEST HERE. I CAN'T SEE IT EVER BEING COST EFFICIENT AS A MUSEUM, AND NEVER PROFITABLE UNDER OPERATION PROTOCOLS FROM MY ERA. AS MUCH AS I ADORE WOODCHESTER VILLA, ITS TRUTHS MUST PREVAIL…..FOR THE WELL BEING OF TAXPAYERS OF THE MUNICIPALITY.